Keep a Krita selection in pixels if its soft edge contains multiple transparency levels that you need to preserve. Consider a vector selection when you need to adjust curve anchors or move and transform the selection while avoiding the kind of resize artifacts associated with pixel selections. Converting pixels to vector loses semi-transparent values, so a soft-edged selection should not be converted by default.
Decide by the selection data and the next edit
Krita lets you choose Pixel or Vector in the selection tool’s Mode options. The manual describes pixel selections as editable with pixel information and vector selections as editable with vector anchor tools. Vector is the default selection mode, but the default is not a reason to convert an existing selection. See the Krita selection manual.
Use this sequence for a character outline such as the hypothetical 600 × 900 canvas in the worksheet below:
- Decide whether the edge is intended to be hard or feathered. If you need a gradual transition, treat the selection’s semi-transparent edge values as data to preserve, not merely a visual effect.
- In the selection tool options, check the Mode label to identify the selection type. Do not infer the type from an icon or color alone.
- If the outline needs repeated curve edits, create or retain a vector selection and use the Shape Edit Tool to adjust anchor points. The manual specifically identifies anchor editing as a way to adjust Bezier curves or add corners.
- If the outline already has soft gray edge values, keep a pixel version for that work. To assess conversion, use a duplicate and compare the original and converted selection in Mask display mode, which shows selection transparency levels.
- Choose the version that passes its intended acceptance check: editable anchors for a hard-edged curve, or retained gray edge values for a feathered boundary.
The manual also says vector selections can be moved and transformed without the kind of resize artifacts associated with pixel selections. That is a reason to consider vector when repeated geometric adjustment matters, not a guarantee that every conversion or edit will preserve all selection properties. For display-mode details, see Krita’s selection display guidance.
Acceptance worksheet for a hypothetical outline
The entries below are hypothetical observations for an author-created comparison, not results from running Krita. Make a duplicate before comparing so the original pixel selection remains available. In Mask display mode, inspect corresponding edge areas before and after conversion. Do not assume a particular number of gray pixels should remain: the manual warns of lost semi-transparent values but does not specify a measurement threshold.
| Hypothetical 600 × 900 outline | Intended edit | Observation on duplicate | Decision and acceptance check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hard-edged curve | Adjust a Bezier bend twice | Shape Edit Tool exposes editable anchors; no feathered edge is intended | Use vector if anchors can be adjusted as needed |
| Feathered shoulder edge | Preserve gradual edge transparency | Mask display shows gray levels before conversion; compare the same boundary after conversion | Keep pixels if those levels disappear or change in the comparison |
| Mixed outline with one soft segment | Refine the hard curve but retain the soft segment | The selection contains multiple transparency levels | Do not convert the whole selection by default; keep the pixel version unless a separate vector edit is essential and the soft-edge loss is acceptable |
This comparison is an author-recommended check, not a claim that Mask mode quantifies values or that every displayed change has a specific numeric cause.
Limits and what to do if it fails
The documented conversion command is Select ‣ Convert to Vector Selection. The warning is specific: when a selection has multiple transparency levels, converting it to vector loses the semi-transparent values. Thus, a vector outline that looks smooth is not sufficient proof that a feathered selection retained its original edge data.
If the duplicate’s soft edge no longer shows the gray levels you need, return to the retained pixel selection for that boundary rather than treating the conversion as reversible. If the converted result lacks the anchor controls you expected, confirm the selection type in the tool options and try the Shape Edit Tool on the vector selection. The manual does not promise that vector selections support painting as vector data: painting on a vector selection mask converts it to a pixel selection. If painting is your next operation, account for that change in type.
Three quick questions
Does a soft-looking boundary mean the selection is vector?
No. Use the Mode label to identify Pixel or Vector. Use Mask display to inspect transparency levels; appearance alone does not establish the selection type.
Can I convert a pixel selection to get editable curve anchors?
Yes. Krita documents conversion through Select ‣ Convert to Vector Selection and describes anchor editing with the Shape Edit Tool. Check first whether the pixel selection contains semi-transparent edge values you cannot afford to lose.
Should I use vector for every smooth outline?
No. If “smooth” means a feathered boundary with gray transparency, preserve the pixel selection unless losing those values is acceptable. If it means a clean curve whose anchors need repeated adjustment, vector is the more relevant choice.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.