If the lower video track must become visible through part of the upper clip, choose a masking effect that creates an alpha channel, such as Alpha Shapes, Rectangular Alpha Mask, Rotoscoping, or Shape Alpha. If the upper clip should remain present while an effect applies only to a selected region, choose the corresponding effect with (Mask) in its name and add Mask Apply. The two choices may use similar shapes, but they control different things: visibility through the clip versus the scope of an effect.
Specific decision and steps
- State the acceptance condition before adding an effect. Use “the lower track is visible here” for an alpha cutout. Use “blur or color changes are limited to this region” for a local effect.
- For a lower-track reveal, add a non-
(Mask)alpha-producing effect. Choose the shape or method that matches the task: a simple geometric shape, edge-based rectangle, rotoscoping for an irregular subject, or an image/video source with an alpha channel throughShape Alpha. - For a local blur or color change, add a matching
(Mask)effect. Place the effects you want to limit in the stack, then addMask Applyso the mask brackets those effects. Kdenlive applies effects from top to bottom; the documented example placesAlpha Shapes (Mask)andMask ApplyaroundGaussian BlurandBw0r. - Decide whether the selected region should be affected or protected. Check the effect's
Operationsetting, and use inversion when the needed area is the complement of the drawn mask. In the documented protected-house example, the masked house is kept out of the blur and black-and-white effects while the rest of the image changes. - Preview the result against a clearly different lower track or a visible color change. Judge the actual result and the effect labels, because a similar-looking outline does not establish whether the effect creates alpha or limits another effect.
For the official distinction between alpha creation and (Mask) effects, see Kdenlive’s masking guide. The broader explanation of mask alpha behavior is in Masking and Tracking.
An acceptance worksheet with new observations
The following is a hypothetical worksheet for a three-clip project. The observations are proposed checks, not a software test or a guarantee of a particular rendering result.
| Hypothetical task and observation | Mask choice | Mask Apply? | Operation or inversion decision | Stack or acceptance decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| “Sky” clip above “street” clip; after enabling the effect, the street should appear only through the selected oval | Alpha Shapes without (Mask) | No | Invert only if the visible opening is opposite to the drawn shape | Approve when the lower street is visible in the intended area and the rest of the upper clip remains present |
| “Portrait” clip; a 12-second Gaussian Blur should affect the background while the face stays sharp | Rotoscoping (Mask) for the face or protected region | Yes | Use the operation or inversion that makes the face the protected area | Keep the mask and Mask Apply around Gaussian Blur; accept only when blur is confined as intended |
| “Interview” clip; a black-and-white effect should affect the background while a 640-pixel-wide subject area remains in color | A suitable (Mask) effect | Yes | Treat the width as a project assumption, then inspect which side is selected and invert if required | Add the black-and-white effect inside the mask scope; accept from the observed color boundary, not from the number alone |
The table uses invented task details to make the decision concrete. The 640-pixel width is an assumption in that task, not a documented universal pixel-count algorithm or a guarantee that a particular Operation value fits every shape. Confirm the selected area in the preview. As an editorial check, compare the effect type shown in the effect name rather than relying on node color; this is a reading suggestion, not documented software behavior.
Limits and the next step after failure
A non-(Mask) effect changes alpha so clips on lower tracks can show through; it does not by itself mean that another effect is restricted to a region. A (Mask) effect needs Mask Apply to limit other effects. If the lower track never appears, inspect whether the chosen effect is an alpha-producing effect and whether its operation leaves the intended area transparent. If the lower track appears but the blur or color effect covers the wrong region, inspect the stack order, add or reposition Mask Apply, and review inversion or Operation.
Rotoscoping is intended for complex, irregular shapes and can use keyframes when the subject moves. Simple shapes are more suitable for geometric areas. The documentation describes the available behavior, but it does not guarantee perfect edge tracking, recovery of hidden image detail, or a particular feathering result. If the boundary moves, adjust mask parameters with keyframes and reassess the visible result.
Three brief questions
Does a mask always make the clip transparent?
No. The effect name and purpose matter. Alpha-producing effects create transparency for lower-track visibility; (Mask) effects define an effect scope when used with Mask Apply.
Do I need `Mask Apply` for showing the track below?
No, when the goal is the alpha cutout itself. Mask Apply is for applying other effects only to the masked scope.
How do I protect the selected area from an effect?
Use a (Mask) effect with Mask Apply, then set Operation or inversion so the selected area is excluded from the effect. Verify the result in the preview.
Sources and next step
- Masking — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
- Masking and Tracking — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the film workspace. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.