The decision depends on two questions: is the file used on the timeline, and could the recipient need it for an agreed revision? Include unused AI takes or source images in the archive when they may be selected, compared, or edited later. Use Archive only timeline clips when the handoff is intentionally limited to the current cut, but record every excluded candidate separately and explain how it will be supplied if needed.
Concrete decision and steps
Kdenlive’s Archive Project function can copy the files required by a project into a folder and can optionally create a tar.gz or zip archive. It also changes the project’s media paths to the archived copies. See the official Archiving documentation.
- Open the project’s Project Files tab and record the media categories and the counts for clips used in the project and unused clips. Kdenlive defines unused clips as project-bin files not yet used on the timeline. This is a classification aid, not permission to delete anything.
- For every unused AI take or source image, mark whether it is needed for a likely revision, client comparison, legal or editorial review, or only for temporary experimentation. If a future editor might reasonably need it, treat it as part of the intended handoff even though it is not on the timeline.
- Choose Archive Project. Kdenlive’s documentation says archiving copies files required by the project, but does not specify that every unused project-bin item is included. If the recipient needs candidate media or broad revision freedom, check the archive dialog and the resulting archive to confirm which files it actually includes; do not assume that a full archive contains every unused item. Select Archive only timeline clips only when the delivery promise is limited to the current timeline’s media.
- Create a separate handoff list for anything excluded: filename, media type, reason for exclusion, original location, and the person responsible for retaining it. When a timeline-only archive is opened, Kdenlive asks what to do with clips that were not archived. The prompt does not restore or supply those files. Use the list to decide whether to provide the original media separately and, if so, update the handoff scope.
- Open the archive from its intended delivery location through Kdenlive’s archived-project file type. Confirm that the project opens, the required timeline media is present, and the result matches the promised scope. A full archive and a timeline-only archive should be accepted against different checklists.
The Project Files documentation also warns that its delete-files action deletes unused files from the file system. Do not interpret an unused count as a safe cleanup recommendation. Read the Project Files documentation before removing anything.
A handoff worksheet with new observations
The following is a proposed acceptance worksheet using hypothetical data. The numbers and observations are examples, not Kdenlive guarantees about counting or archive size.
| Media | Type | Timeline use | Needed for revision? | Archive choice | Handling if excluded | Acceptance observation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
take_A03.mp4 | AI-generated video candidate | No | Yes, client may compare openings | Confirm inclusion in archive | If absent, provide separately or revise scope | Check whether it is present after extraction |
hero-source.png | Source image | No | Yes, possible crop change | Confirm inclusion in archive | If absent, provide separately or revise scope | Check whether it is available to the archived project |
temp-motion-02.mp4 | AI-generated video candidate | No | No, rejected after review | Timeline-only archive | Retain original separately and list it | Archive opens without requiring this candidate for the current cut |
cut_v7.mp4 | Video clip | Yes | Yes | Either, according to scope | None | Timeline plays through required sections |
The worksheet’s useful question is not “is this file AI-generated?” but “what revision or review promise would fail if this file were absent?” That keeps the archive decision tied to the recipient’s work rather than to the label or color of an item in the project bin. Use the actual media type and filename as the record; visual cues are only clues.
Limits and next steps after failure
The documentation establishes copying, optional compression, timeline-only selection, and the prompt for non-archived clips. It does not promise that every future candidate should be included, that an archive preserves an unlimited revision history, or that an archive can reconstruct files that were already missing. It also does not define a universal size or count calculation for AI media.
If the archive fails to open, first keep the original project and excluded-media list unchanged. Reopen from the extracted delivery location and inspect which required item is unavailable. If a file was intentionally excluded, supply it through the separately documented handoff path and revise the scope statement. If the current cut itself depends on a missing file, the archive was not accepted as a timeline playback handoff; resolve that dependency before delivering it.
Three short questions
Should every unused AI take be archived? No. Include it when later selection, comparison, or revision is part of the handoff. Otherwise list and retain it separately.
Does “unused” mean safe to delete? No. The documented delete action can remove files from the file system. Use project cleanup only after confirming retention needs.
What should the recipient receive? A project archive that matches the promised scope, plus an explicit list of excluded media and its retention location when the archive is timeline-only.
Sources and next step
- Archiving — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
- Project Files — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
- File Management — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the film workspace. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.