Adjust Softness when the wipe pattern and reveal path are already correct but the boundary is too hard or too diffuse. Set it to zero when the intended result is a sharp edge. Choose another Wipe Method when the reveal shape or path itself is wrong. Changing Softness cannot turn a radial reveal into a horizontal bar, and changing the method will not by itself provide the desired edge transition. The diagnostic order is therefore: hold the composition track, transition interval, and wipe method constant; judge the edge; then inspect the path and direction settings.
Specific Judgment and Steps
- Select the Wipe composition or transition and identify the
Composition Track. In the Wipe transition,Automaticuses the track immediately below, while the available manual choices are restricted to lower-numbered tracks. Confirm the actual track label rather than inferring behavior from clip color or position. - Keep the transition duration and the current
Wipe Methodunchanged. Watch the reveal over its full interval, not only on a frame where the boundary is stationary. Decide whether the path is appropriate: for example, a horizontal bar should travel horizontally, while a radial pattern should open around a center. - If the path is appropriate and only the boundary looks abrupt, adjust
Softness. The official documentation defines this as the feathering control;Softnessset to zero creates a sharp edge. Increase it in small, deliberate steps and compare the same frame and viewing scale. - If the path or shape is inappropriate, return Softness to the comparison value and select another
Wipe Method. Kdenlive provides built-in methods and can also use installed or local grayscale wipe files. Treat that selection as a separate variable from edge feathering. - Check
InvertandRevertindependently. The Wipe documentation describesInvertas reversing the method's direction andRevertas reversing the transition direction, including which track is revealed first. Record their states so a directional problem is not mistaken for a bad pattern.
The official controls and their relationships are documented in Kdenlive's Wipe manual. The same distinction appears for same-track transitions: Kdenlive Mixes / Same-track Transitions identifies Softness as feathering and zero as a hard edge.
Acceptance Worksheet
The following is an editorial comparison method using hypothetical requirements. The observations are checkpoints, not guarantees about a particular wipe file or render.
| Hypothetical requirement | Fixed items | Only changed item | Direction record | Acceptance observation | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sharp geometric edge | Track, interval, Bar Horizontal, Softness=0 | None after setup | Invert off, Revert on | Boundary remains visually crisp while the bar follows the intended side | Keep method and zero softness |
| Softer edge with the same reveal | Track, interval, Bar Horizontal, direction states | Softness from 0 to a modest comparison value | Same as prior row | The bar path is unchanged; only the transition band appears broader | Keep method and tune Softness |
| Reveal from a different spatial route | Track, interval, initial softness | Wipe Method changed to a suitable radial or vertical example | Record Invert and Revert separately | The new shape reaches the intended region; softness is judged afterward | Keep the new method only if its path fits |
For each row, write the observed method name and settings beside the preview. This makes the comparison reproducible without assuming that a particular numeric softness value is universal.
Limits and Next Steps After Failure
If a softened edge still looks wrong, first ask whether the wipe path is wrong. A broad feather can make an unsuitable pattern less conspicuous without correcting the reveal geometry. Conversely, replacing a correct method merely because its edge is sharp changes two decisions at once and makes the result harder to diagnose.
None (Dissolve) is a special case in the documented list: it performs a simple dissolve and the Softness slider has no effect. If that is selected, changing Softness cannot solve the transition appearance; choose a wipe method whose spatial pattern matches the requirement. Custom or downloaded grayscale wipes may also behave differently because their shape comes from the image used as the wipe. The documentation does not establish a universal softness value, pixel width, or guaranteed visual result for each method.
If the reveal direction is wrong after choosing a suitable method, compare Invert and Revert one at a time while leaving the method and Softness unchanged. If the transition is on the wrong clips or track, inspect the composition-track selection before changing the visual controls. These are proposed isolation steps based on the documented controls, not a report of completed software testing.
Three Short Questions
Does zero Softness always mean the whole transition is abrupt?
It means the wipe edge is sharp according to the documentation. It does not change the selected pattern, transition duration, or which track is selected.
Should I change the Wipe Method when I only want less haloing?
Usually no. If the reveal route is correct, keep the method and adjust Softness. Change the method only when the shape or path does not fit the visual requirement.
Is `Revert` the same as `Invert`?
No. Kdenlive documents them as separate direction controls. Record each state independently and compare one setting at a time rather than treating them as interchangeable.
Sources and next step
- Wipe — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
- Mixes / Same-track Transitions — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the film workspace. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.