The reliable way to verify a rounded or circular picture-in-picture window is to separate four decisions: the boundary shape, its rounding or radius, the padding color including alpha, and the position and scale of the selected image area. In Kdenlive, Crop by Padding is documented for cropping to a rounded rectangle or circle by padding the edges with a specified color. It can also be used for picture-in-picture work. Treat the monitor composite, rather than the control values alone, as the acceptance view.
Specific checks and steps
- Add Crop by Padding to the picture-in-picture clip and decide the intended shape. Leave
Circleoff for a rounded rectangle; switch it on when the window must be circular. The official control changes the crop interpretation, whileRadiuscontrols the circular or rectangular rounding. See the official Crop by Padding documentation.
- Set
Padding Coloraccording to the delivery requirement. Use a visible color when the border or filled padding is part of the design. Use an alpha value when the edge must be transparent. Do not approve a color that merely resembles transparency on one background.
- Set
Position X,Position Y,Size W,Size H, andScaleas a group. These controls determine where the rectangle or circle sits in the frame, how large it is, and which portion of the source is brought into the window. Check the subject's headroom, hands, text, and other important edges inside the monitor.
- Place the clip over the real lower layer and inspect the composite at the intended viewing size. Check the entire boundary, not only the center: confirm that the lower layer appears wherever alpha padding is expected, that no unintended source region remains visible, and that the subject is not clipped by the chosen window.
- Repeat the inspection with the other required shape. A circular window and a rounded rectangle do not establish the same boundary contract. Record the approved shape, radius, padding type, position, size, scale, and the visible result for each version.
The effect supports keyframes according to the documentation, but that does not by itself prove that an animated boundary has been reviewed. If any of these values change over time, inspect representative moments where the subject approaches an edge.
Acceptance worksheet with a new observation
The following is a hypothetical review record, not a measured Kdenlive result or a guarantee about a particular numeric combination. The values illustrate how to connect a setting to an observable decision.
| Version | Assumed settings | Composite observation | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rounded rectangle | Circle off; Radius 24; Padding Color alpha; Position X 820, Y 90; Size W 420, H 280; Scale 100% | Lower video is visible around the rounded corners; face and caption remain inside the frame | Accept if the transparent corners are required |
| Circle | Circle on; Radius 210; same position and scale | Subject's right hand is cut by the circular boundary while the lower layer shows at the edge | Adjust source framing or size before approval |
| Filled border | Circle off; Padding Color opaque white; same geometry | Corners appear white on both a dark and bright lower layer | Accept only when white padding is intentional; it is not an alpha result |
| Unexpected rectangle | Circle appears off or the radius is unsuitable; other values unchanged | Square corners remain visible in the monitor | Recheck the actual Circle control and inspect the effect result |
The color in a picker is only a clue. Confirm the actual padding type, especially whether it carries alpha, through the composite result and the control’s value.
Limits and next steps after failure
Crop by Padding defines a shape, padding, and geometric placement. The cited documentation does not promise object-aware tracking, automatic subject protection, or recovery of details that were already outside the source crop. If a face or graphic is clipped, first decide whether the window is too small, the source view is poorly framed, or the position and scale are wrong. Then change the relevant geometric control and review the composite again.
If transparent corners do not reveal the lower layer, inspect the padding value and the receiving composite rather than darkening or lightening the color. A solid color is a filled border, not evidence of transparency. If a required animated change is present, review more than one timeline position; a single good frame is insufficient for a moving window.
Three short questions
Should I use a circle or a rounded rectangle?
Use Circle when the intended boundary is circular. Keep it off when the window needs independent rectangular width and height with rounded corners. Decide from the required silhouette, not from the clip’s current appearance.
Does `Radius` choose the subject area?
No. Radius describes the boundary rounding or circular crop. The source area and its placement must be judged with Position X/Y, Size W/H, and Scale in the monitor.
How do I prove the edge is transparent?
Place the picture-in-picture over a lower layer with visible detail and verify that the lower layer appears through the intended padding. A background that happens to match the padding color is not sufficient evidence.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the film workspace. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.