If you want a merged copy of GIMP’s current visible appearance while keeping the original layers, choose Layer → New from Visible. GIMP creates a new layer at the top of the layer stack from the visible layers, while the original visible layers remain. Use Image → Merge Visible Layers only when you intend the visible layers to be replaced by one merged layer.
Decide and act
Use this decision rule:
- Choose
New from Visiblewhen you may need to revise the source layers, compare alternatives, or continue editing the composite with a blur or mask. - Choose
Merge Visible Layerswhen the original visible layers no longer need to remain separate and the document should contain their replacement as one layer. - If hidden layers must also be removed, the merge dialog provides a
Discard invisible layersoption. Treat that as a separate cleanup decision, not as a consequence of making a visible composite.
Follow these steps:
- In the Layers dialog, identify which layers have the eye icon. Those are the layers included by the visible-layer commands. Turn visibility on or off according to the appearance you intend to capture.
- For a retained source, open the Layer menu and select New from Visible. The result should appear as a new top layer. Rename it according to the project’s own naming scheme, such as
composite-for-blur. - Continue on that new layer. For example, apply a selective blur and add a layer mask so parts of the original work can show through. This is a project workflow choice; the command itself does not decide where the mask or blur belongs.
- For replacement instead, use Image → Merge Visible Layers. Review the merge options, especially the final layer boundary and whether invisible layers should be discarded, before confirming. The visible originals disappear after the merge.
The official New from Visible documentation describes the retained top-layer result. The Merge Visible Layers documentation distinguishes it from replacement and lists the merge options.
Acceptance worksheet
The following is a proposed comparison method, not a completed software test. Work on a duplicate of the layered document and record the observations:
| Hypothetical setup or observation | Decision | Expected structural check |
|---|---|---|
| Three layers are visible; two adjustment-like artwork layers must remain available for revision | Use New from Visible | A new top composite is present and the three source entries remain in the stack |
| The composite needs a blur and a mask, while the source artwork must stay recoverable | Use New from Visible | Blur and mask are assigned to the new composite, not used as evidence that the sources were merged |
| The visible result is approved and only one editable replacement layer is wanted | Use Merge Visible Layers | The original visible entries are gone and one merged visible result remains |
| A hidden backup layer must be retained for later comparison | Do not select Discard invisible layers | The hidden layer remains; visibility itself does not prove that it was included in the composite |
Compare the layer names and visibility states, not just the canvas appearance. An exported image can look correct while providing no evidence that its component layers remain editable.
Limits and next step
New from Visible preserves the source layers, but it does not make the resulting composite semantically separate into its original objects. After blur, paint, or other edits on the composite, those edits are on that new layer unless your own workflow uses a mask or another layer structure.
Merge Visible Layers is a structural replacement. If you chose the wrong visible set, boundary option, or hidden-layer disposal setting, stop before further edits and return to the duplicate or an earlier saved layered document. Do not infer the exact pixel extent from the command name; read the available boundary choices in the dialog. If the result is clipped or unexpectedly scoped, inspect that dialog choice and the layer stack before changing artwork.
Three quick questions
Does `New from Visible` include hidden layers?
The command is defined around the visible result. A layer without the eye icon is not part of the visible set used for this decision.
Does merging visible layers keep the originals underneath?
No. The official description says the original visible layers disappear. Hidden layers are a separate case controlled by the merge dialog.
Which command is better for a selective blur?
Use New from Visible, then blur the new composite and apply the mask arrangement required by the project. This keeps the source layer structure available for comparison or revision.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.