When a feathered selection touches the canvas edge, one side can remain sharp because GIMP’s Feather dialog has a setting that treats the selected area as continuing beyond the image. The manual’s example says that, with this option checked, a selection along the image border does not feather on that border; turning it off changes that edge behavior. This is a selection-boundary setting, not a brush-softness or export-format setting.
What the edge option changes
Choose Select → Feather to open the Feather Selection dialog. Set the feather width there, then inspect Selected areas continue outside the image. When enabled, GIMP calculates as though the selected area extends beyond the canvas boundary. At a border, that can leave the boundary side unfeathered even while the other sides transition.
The key diagnostic is whether the sharp side coincides with the canvas boundary. A hard edge only at the top, bottom, left, or right points first to this option. If the selection is fully inside the canvas and its edges are still hard, this explanation may not apply; inspect whether the feather was applied to the intended selection.
Compare the setting in a controlled way
Use a small test selection in a working image, or a clearly distinguishable area where you can judge the transition. Keep the feather width and selection geometry fixed while comparing the option. Test each side separately: a rectangle touching only the top, then only the bottom, left, and right. That avoids confusing a border-specific effect with a corner where two edges meet.
- Create a selection that touches exactly one canvas edge, leaving the other three edges inside the image.
- Open Select → Feather and note the current width and checkbox state for Selected areas continue outside the image.
- Apply Feather and inspect the selection preview, especially the side touching the canvas and the three interior sides.
- Recreate the same selection, use the same width, switch the checkbox state, and apply Feather again. Do not compare different shapes or widths as if the checkbox were the only change.
- Repeat the pair of observations for the other three canvas edges.
- If the result will control a mask or fill, inspect the resulting edge in that use as well as the selection preview; the marching-ants outline alone is not a complete view of the graded transition.
Record what you see
The values below are hypothetical observations, not GIMP test results. “Transition visible” means the preview or applied mask/fill shows a gradual edge rather than an abrupt cutoff. Record your own result because selection geometry and the chosen width affect what is visible.
| Edge tested | Continue outside checked | Continue outside unchecked | Interior sides | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top only | Hypothetical: canvas-side edge looks sharp | Hypothetical: a transition is visible | Compare the same three sides | Note width and preview |
| Bottom only | Hypothetical: canvas-side edge looks sharp | Hypothetical: a transition is visible | Compare the same three sides | Note width and applied result |
| Left only | Hypothetical: canvas-side edge looks sharp | Hypothetical: a transition is visible | Compare the same three sides | Note any corner interaction |
| Right only | Hypothetical: canvas-side edge looks sharp | Hypothetical: a transition is visible | Compare the same three sides | Note width and applied result |
For example, if a test uses a hypothetical 12 px feather and only the top-touching selection changes at the top when you toggle the option, that observation supports a border-setting explanation for that setup. It does not establish that 12 px is right for the artwork, or that every other edge will look identical.
If the border still looks hard
First confirm that the checkbox actually changed between otherwise equivalent comparisons and that Feather was applied after selecting the intended area. Check the three interior sides: if those also remain abrupt, the issue may not be limited to the canvas-edge rule. Recreate a single-edge test and compare again before changing the width.
Then check both representations you care about: the selection preview and the result where the selection is used, such as a layer mask or fill. A visible selection boundary is not, by itself, a measurement of the mask’s partial opacity. The supplied documentation explains the edge option’s behavior but does not specify a universal pixel profile for every geometry or downstream use. Do not infer an exact transition width from the marching-ants outline alone.
Common questions
Is this caused by a soft brush?
Not by the Feather dialog behavior described here. GIMP also offers “Feather Edges” in selection tools, but a sharp canvas-side edge in the Feather command calls for checking Selected areas continue outside the image first.
Should I always turn the option off?
No. Compare both states for the edge you need. The setting changes how GIMP treats a selection at or beyond the image boundary; the appropriate result depends on whether you want that boundary side feathered.
Does a larger feather width fix the sharp side?
The manual identifies the checkbox as the border-related behavior, not a particular width as a fix. Keep width constant while diagnosing the option, then choose a width based on the transition required by your mask or fill and inspect the applied result.
Sources
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.