
Different Ha and OIII dimensions can be a documented extraction result rather than a failed file save. In Siril's Bayer dual-band workflow, Ha comes from the red CFA samples, while OIII is built from the green and blue samples. The resampling choice determines whether the outputs retain different sizes or are reconciled to a common grid.
Confirm that the captured filter supports the intended interpretation
Start with a real one-shot-color session taken through the relevant dual-band filter. Record the filter and camera rather than inferring spectral content from a red-looking preview.
The Siril 1.4.4 extraction reference requires a properly documented Bayer matrix in a supporting image format. It explicitly excludes X-Trans. A finished RGB photograph and a CFA capture are different input representations.
Preserve the calibrated mosaic when following the CFA extraction workflow. This is not an instruction to label any ordinary red channel as measured H-alpha.
Understand the unequal sample grids
Only one location in a Bayer two-by-two cell is red. Packing those samples into a separate Ha image gives half the source width and height.
The documented OIII construction uses the other color locations and interpolation. Consequently an unresampled extraction can produce full-size OIII alongside half-size Ha. A short introductory description of channel extraction should not be treated as a guarantee that every selected resampling mode produces identical dimensions.
This differs from a print-resolution label. Changing PPI metadata does not reconcile the grids.
Choose the intended resampling result
Inspect Ha/OIII resampling before combining the outputs:
| Documented choice | Intended size relationship |
|---|---|
| No resampling | Keep full-size OIII and half-size Ha |
| Upsample Ha | Enlarge Ha to match OIII |
| Downsample OIII | Reduce OIII to match Ha |
Retain the original extraction when comparing alternatives. An enlarged Ha file does not contain a newly captured red sample at every output location.
The manual also describes a sequence-based Drizzle alternative for Ha; that requires the corresponding per-frame extraction and stacking workflow. It is not a one-image resize switch.
Verify channel identity and common framing
Check the actual dimensions, corresponding star positions and retained field boundaries before constructing a color composite. Equal canvas sizes alone do not prove aligned content.
Do not run a generic demosaicing comparison over an already extracted mono channel as though it still contained the original Bayer layout.
No filtered captures were separated or resampled here. This guide explains the documented output geometry, without claiming spectral purity, a performed reconstruction or recovery of missing samples.
Related tasks
- How Large Can You Print a Generated Image?
- Why Do Fine Lines Turn into Colored Moiré After Demosaicing in darktable 5.6?
Sources and scope
- Siril 1.4.4: Channel Extraction — Extract Ha/OIII: Ha uses red Bayer samples, giving half width/height. OIII combines green/blue and interpolates missing locations; no-resampling, upsample-Ha and downsample-OIII have distinct output sizes. Requires documented Bayer CFA, excludes X-Trans.
Official Siril or ExifTool project documentation was opened and read on October 23, 2026 (Asia/Shanghai). Siril versioned pages identify 1.4.4. ExifTool project-site HTML access was restricted, while the cited official repository document was readable. No acquisition, decoding, extraction, PSF generation, synthesis, metadata command or repair was performed. The cover is decorative.
Prepared by Imagild Editorial, the company editorial team responsible for these guides. AI assisted research and drafting. This is documentation-based guidance with proposed examples, not a claim of hands-on testing or an independent product review. Report a correction.
Cover: Mariya Eskina / Pexels, Pexels License. This is an illustrative source photograph, not an application screenshot or a generated test result.