Photoshop Replace Contents retains the Smart Object's transformations. That is useful for updating a mockup, but the replacement artwork still needs compatible composition and source geometry. A different aspect ratio or internal margin can make the new design appear cropped, stretched in context, or poorly positioned.
Compare the source canvases
Inspect the old artwork's dimensions, orientation, and placement inside its source canvas. Compare those with the replacement. A square image containing wide empty margins is not equivalent to tightly cropped square artwork, even though the outer dimensions match.
Imagine an approved postcard mockup whose placeholder contains a full-bleed landscape design. Replacing it with a portrait illustration plus white padding may preserve the mockup transform while placing the useful artwork in the wrong part of the card. The mockup can be functioning as documented while the source contract is wrong.
Prepare a compatible replacement
- Record the placeholder canvas and the visible area intended for the design.
- Place the approved new artwork into a source document with a deliberate canvas and margins.
- Replace the Smart Object contents through the supported command, then inspect the resulting composition.
- Check corners, text, bleed-facing edges, and identifying proportions before rendering the presentation image.
Do not keep warping an already distorted replacement until it looks roughly correct. Return to the source geometry when the useful content occupies the wrong area of its canvas.
Separate three deliverables
| Asset | What to verify |
|---|---|
| Flat artwork | Correct dimensions, margins, and editable content |
| Mockup source | Compatible canvas for the retained transformation |
| Presentation render | Plausible perspective without misleading artwork cropping |
An Imagild-generated image can supply creative artwork, but a mockup preview is not a print-ready version of that artwork. Keep the flat delivery separate and review any typography or product details that must remain exact.
Questions about replacement
Does Replace Contents remove all transforms? Adobe documents that transformations are retained.
Does the same pixel count guarantee the same layout? No. Aspect ratio and internal content placement also matter.
Should I judge print dimensions from the mockup? Use the flat artwork specification and the supplier's template instead of the perspective presentation.
Sources and next step
The examples and review checks are editorial guidance, not reported application tests. For a subsequent transformation, open the Imagild photo editor with the specific approved input or brief described above.
Related reading: Why Don’t Photoshop Layer Comps Restore My Old Text?; Why Does My Knockout Text Reveal the Wrong Background?; Why Does Replacing One Photoshop Smart Object Change Every Product Slot?.