For a cel-shaded illustration that needs separate color edits, choose Split Into Layers; for a more painterly image where your next move is selecting several colored areas together, choose Split Into Local Selection Masks. Decide from the edit you need and the kind of result Krita must create—not from whichever choice produces fewer entries. The examples below are hypothetical planning and acceptance checks, not test results.
Choose from the next edit
Krita’s Split Layer manual describes these as two different kinds of output: one produces paint layers from the image’s colors; the other produces local selection masks. Use this sequence to make the choice:
- Write down the next edit. If you need to repaint one color area independently, choose paint layers. If you need to select several color areas for a subsequent operation, choose local selection masks.
- Select the source layer and open Split Layer. Decide on the output type in the dialog’s dropdown before judging any other options.
- Treat visual style as a clue, not a rule. Clearly separated flats often suit the paint-layer route; a more painterly image may suit masks when combined selections are the goal. The actual editing task takes priority over style labels.
- Inspect the generated entries by their actual object type or properties, then check whether the intended next action is possible. Node color or icon can be a clue, but do not use it as proof of type. A useful acceptance check is whether a paint edit stays on its intended paint layer, or whether the desired areas can be selected together using the masks.
Hypothetical acceptance worksheet
The figures below are invented inspection notes, not predicted counts or guaranteed results. The manual does not promise how many entries a particular image will produce.
| Assumed input and goal | Hypothetical observation | Decision and acceptance check |
|---|---|---|
| Cel-shaded character with five intended broad color areas; recolor one area at a time. | A hypothetical run shows six entries, each identified on inspection as a paint layer. | Keep this output only if the intended area can be edited independently without changing the other areas; the entry count alone does not pass the check. |
| Grainy painted image with two separated patches to select together; no need for a separate pixel layer per color. | A hypothetical run shows twelve local selection masks; the artist’s check confirms the two intended patches can be selected together. | Keep this output if the selection suits the next operation and the entries are masks, not paint layers. Do not treat twelve as an expected count. |
Limits and what to try next
The manual notes that some options below the output choice are unavailable for local selection masks because those objects are not paint layers. If an option is absent in that mode, do not assume the split failed; check whether that option is relevant to the object type. If you need independently editable pixels, rerun with paint-layer output. If you only need a selection to guide a later edit, keep the mask route and carry out that edit on a suitable paint layer.
Fuzziness is a separate decision from output type. The manual’s description of fuzziness says that higher fuzziness means less precise matching and notes its relevance to anti-aliased edges: without it, tiny pixel differences can lead to separate layers. If your result is unexpectedly fragmented, compare runs with cautious fuzziness adjustments on a working copy and inspect the boundaries. The documentation does not define a universal setting or promise a particular number of results, so do not tune toward a target count. If the real problem is the wrong kind of output, change the dropdown instead.
Three quick questions
Does a smaller result count mean a better split? No. Accept the result based on object type and whether it supports your next edit, not on fewer entries.
Should I hide the original layer? The dialog lists a Hide the original layer option. Use it if the visible source makes the results harder to inspect; hiding it changes visibility, not the split’s purpose.
Can a palette control how the image is split? The documented palette option is for naming layers by comparing a layer’s main color with palette colors. Treat it as a naming aid, not as a way to choose between paint layers and masks.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.