Choose the drop target based on what you may need to change later: drag a palette swatch to the layer stack to create a fill layer; drag it to the canvas to fill the current layer. To fill the whole layer, or just the part within the current selection, hold Alt while dropping on the canvas. These are distinct outcomes, not three names for the same fill.
Choose the target and apply the swatch
For a character illustration, use a fill layer when a color should remain independently replaceable. Use a canvas drop when you intend to change the current layer itself. If the canvas operation should be limited to a selected region, establish that selection first and use the documented Alt drop behavior.
- Identify the intended result: a new fill layer, a change to the current layer, or a change limited to the selection.
- If the result depends on a selection, make that selection before applying the swatch. Check that it outlines the intended region.
- Drag the chosen swatch from the palette onto the layer stack for a fill layer, or onto the canvas for a current-layer fill.
- For a whole-layer fill or a fill restricted to the selection, hold
Altas you drop the swatch onto the canvas. The fill options come from the Fill Tool. - Inspect the layer stack and the visibly affected area. If future recoloring matters, confirm that the result is a separate fill layer rather than a change to existing layer content.
Krita documents the two drop targets and the Alt behavior in its Palette Docker manual. The reference to Fill Tool options matters: the palette drop uses those options, so check their current settings if the result is unexpected. The manual does not specify a universal pixel-level result for every possible tool configuration.
Compare three hypothetical outcomes
The following worksheet is an author-recommended comparison method, not a report of a software test. Assume the same red swatch, one current paint layer, and a selection covering the character’s sleeve. Record what actually happens in your document; the table’s observations are hypothetical, not guaranteed results.
| Route using the same swatch | Hypothetical layer-stack observation | Hypothetical affected area | Recolor separately later? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drop on layer stack | A fill layer appears | The artwork view shows the fill-layer result | Yes, as a separate layer |
Drop on canvas without Alt | No new fill layer is intended | The current layer is filled using Fill Tool options | Not as a separate fill layer |
Hold Alt and drop on canvas with sleeve selected | No new fill layer is intended | The fill is limited to the selected portion of the layer | Not as a separate fill layer |
To verify your own case, compare the layer list before and after, then toggle the resulting layer’s visibility or inspect the affected region. Finally, try changing the fill-layer color only if the result is a fill layer; the point of this check is to confirm separate editability, not to assume that every canvas fill has an equivalent independent color control.
Limits and what to do if it fails
A selection constrains the Alt canvas fill according to the manual, but the documented behavior does not define how every selection shape or Fill Tool option will look in a particular file. Treat the selection outline and the visible result as separate checks. If an Alt drop changes more than intended, inspect whether the selection was active and review the Fill Tool settings before repeating the operation.
If dropping on the stack does not produce the expected object, confirm that the swatch was dropped onto the layer stack rather than the canvas, then inspect the stack for a new fill layer. If the stack changed but the visible color is unexpected, inspect the resulting layer and the document’s current appearance instead of assuming the swatch itself was wrong. For direct fills, remember that the target is existing layer content; choose the fill-layer route when keeping the color independently replaceable is a requirement.
Common questions
Does a canvas drop always fill the whole layer? Not necessarily. The manual says it fills the current layer and notes that holding Alt fills the whole layer or the portion inside the current selection. Check the selection and Fill Tool options.
Does `Alt` create a fill layer? No. The documented Alt behavior applies when dropping onto the canvas; dropping onto the layer stack is the documented route for creating a fill layer.
Which route is better if the color may change later? Choose the layer-stack route when separate recoloring is important. Choose a canvas fill when changing the current layer is the intended result.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.