Keep the Krita File Layer linked when the referenced file remains the authoritative artwork and your Krita task only needs placement or deformation. Do not keep it as the only working layer when you must paint directly on the artwork: Krita documents that File Layers cannot currently be painted on. In that case, plan a separate editable layer or an intentional conversion workflow rather than treating a transform mask as rasterization.
Concrete Decision and Steps
Use this order:
- Name the owner of the source. If an illustrator or another application will continue maintaining the external file, keep the File Layer. If the current Krita document must contain the brush edits, a File Layer alone does not meet the requirement.
- Classify the required operation. Positioning, scaling, rotation, or deformation points toward a transformation mask attached to the File Layer. Brush strokes, erasing, or pixel retouching require a paintable internal layer planned for that work. A mask changes how the referenced layer is transformed; it does not turn the reference into internal pixels. See Krita’s File Layers documentation.
- Preserve the source relationship before conversion. Krita can convert a selected set of layers through
Convert > to File Layer. The documented result is an external saved file that replaces the original layer set with a File Layer pointing to that file. Confirm the save location and retain the original arrangement when it may still be needed. - Validate the dependency. The File Layer must keep access to its source. Krita stores a relative path in the
.kra; moving the.krawithout the referenced file can break the link. Reopen the working document from its intended folder and check that the source still resolves. The layer’s folder control can open the referenced file, while its properties can point to another file; changing that target changes the dependency, not the pixels inside the.kra.
A New Acceptance Worksheet
This hypothetical cover illustration uses cover-source.kra as the external authority. The worksheet records observations, not guarantees about unlisted internals.
| Check | Hypothetical observation | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Source ownership | The illustrator is expected to revise cover-source.kra after layout approval | Keep the File Layer linked |
| Krita-only change | The layout needs a 12-degree rotation and a perspective adjustment, but no brush marks | Use a transformation mask; do not rasterize merely for placement |
| Direct painting request | A small highlight must be painted into the illustration in Krita | Add or plan a separate paintable internal layer; do not paint on the File Layer |
| Source update | The external file is saved, then the document is reopened and the artwork reflects the revised cover element | The link is behaving as intended; record the source path |
| Relocation check | After moving the .kra, Krita asks for the missing source file | Treat the relative-path dependency as unresolved and restore or relink the intended source |
| Conversion record | A selected layer group was converted and the original group is no longer in the stack | Confirm that replacement was intentional and keep the source or prior document separately |
Limits and Next Steps After Failure
A File Layer does not display animations according to the cited manual, so animation requirements need a different documented workflow. A transform mask also does not provide direct painting access and should not be described as an internal pixel conversion.
If the source cannot be found, first identify the intended file and use the File Layer properties to point to it. If the wrong revision appears, compare the external file and the recorded source path before editing the layout. If direct retouching is essential, create the paintable content in a suitable internal layer and document whether it belongs above, below, or alongside the linked artwork. If conversion replaced needed layers, stop further edits, locate the preserved document or source copy, and rebuild the conversion from that known state.
Three Short Questions
Does a transformation mask make the File Layer editable?
It makes transformation possible through the mask. It does not make the File Layer paintable or convert it into a raster layer.
Should I convert immediately because I need one correction?
Not necessarily. If the correction can be isolated on a paintable internal layer, keeping the source linked preserves future external updates. Convert only when the working requirement genuinely calls for a new external File Layer representation, and confirm that replacement is acceptable.
What should I verify before delivery?
Reopen the .kra from its delivery location, confirm the intended source resolves, check that the transformation remains visible, and verify that any promised brush edits are on an actually paintable internal layer rather than on the File Layer.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.