If a Kdenlive composite transition uses the wrong image, inspect its Composition Track: Automatic reads the track immediately below the track where the composition originates. To use material on another track, select that track explicitly. For a Wipe composition, the documented control only offers tracks with lower numbers than the originating track. If the intended target does not meet that rule, it is not selectable under the documented rule; the documentation does not say that track numbers can be changed or establish how they map to vertical screen position.
Trace the transition’s track address
A transition bar’s track and its Composition Track answer different questions. The bar sits on the track where the composition originates; that track supplies the blend layer. Composition Track selects the base layer the blend is combined with. This is why a transition can exist and still interact with the adjacent image instead of the one you intended. Kdenlive’s blending documentation describes this origin/base distinction.
Use this ordered check when the wrong shot appears in a composite:
- Select the transition composition itself, not just either video clip. Read its Composition Type and Composition Track properties. Use the property label to identify the setting; track color alone is only a visual clue.
- Identify the timeline track carrying the transition bar. Call it the originating track. Identify the track immediately below it, because that is the target selected by Automatic.
- Locate the intended base footage. If it is on that immediate lower track, compare the result before changing anything. If it is on a different lower track, change Composition Track to that track.
- Check track numbering before choosing a target. The Wipe documentation says that only tracks with lower numbers than the originating track can be selected. If the desired footage has a number that is not lower, it is not selectable under that documented rule. The documentation does not say that track numbers can be changed; changing where the composition originates would be a separate timeline-structure adjustment, not a documented guarantee of a fix. Track numbering alone does not establish vertical screen position. Wipe transition settings document the Automatic and lower-number constraints.
- Play across the composition and confirm that the visible base is the intended shot. A property value or a transition bar proves the setting exists, not that the intended pair of images is actually being combined.
Keep transition direction separate from track addressing. Kdenlive documents controls for transition direction and reversal, but changing those does not by itself select a different base track. First establish which two tracks are participating; then assess whether the visual direction is also wrong.
Use a three-track worksheet
The following is a hypothetical example, not a guaranteed output or a measurement of Kdenlive. Track numbers are illustrative only. Imagine a composition originating on track 3, with intended footage on track 1 and unrelated footage on track 2.
| Origin track number | Automatic target | Intended target | Is target number lower than origin? | Hypothetical observation and decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | 2 | 1 | Yes | Preview shows track 2; explicitly select track 1, then check whether track 1 appears as the base. |
| 3 | 2 | 2 | Yes | The address matches the intended track; if the image still seems wrong, inspect the clips and composition settings rather than changing the address. |
| 2 | 1 | 3 | No | Track 3 is not selectable under the documented lower-number rule. Any change to the composition origin would be a separate timeline-structure adjustment, not a guaranteed fix; this table does not assert a vertical screen position. |
For your own timeline, fill in the four address fields before adjusting wipe appearance or blend settings: origin, Automatic target, intended base, and is the target number lower than the origin? Then record what image actually appears during playback. This separates an addressing mismatch from a visual-setting problem.
Limits and the next check
The documentation establishes which track Automatic chooses and which direction explicit selection permits. It does not promise that changing the Composition Track will produce a particular visual result for every clip, opacity, or composition type. A correct address is necessary for the intended pairing, but is not proof that the entire composite is correct.
If the intended lower track is selected but the preview still does not show the expected image, reselect the composition and verify its labeled type and track property. Then compare the timeline contents at the same playback position: confirm the intended footage is present on the target track and inspect which image is visibly acting as the base. If the problem is instead that the composition uses the wrong transition operation, investigate its Composition Type separately; track selection and transition style are different controls. Do not treat a color change, softness adjustment, or direction reversal as evidence that the base track changed.
Three quick questions
Does Automatic mean the nearest visible clip?
No. The documented rule is the track immediately below the originating track, not whichever clip looks visually nearest in the timeline.
Can I select a track with a higher number than the composition?
The Wipe settings document only lower-numbered tracks as selectable. A higher-numbered target is not selectable under that documented rule. The source does not say that track numbers can be changed or establish that numbering corresponds to a track being physically above the origin.
How do I know the fix worked?
Play through the composition and confirm that the intended shot participates as the base. Do not accept the result solely because a transition bar exists or a property displays the chosen track.
Sources and next step
- Composite Transitions — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
- Wipe — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
- Blending Modes — Kdenlive 26.08 Manual 26.08 documentation
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the film workspace. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.