If a sky becomes patchy after Image → Mode → Indexed, the conversion has fewer available colors than the original image. Start with the highest palette limit your delivery allows, then compare None with each available dithering filter on the actual image. GIMP documents a default maximum of 256 colors for its optimum palette; lowering that limit can create banding in smooth transitions. Dithering may reduce the visible patches by arranging palette colors in pixel clusters, but no filter is guaranteed to be best for every image. Keep the full-color master, and judge the result at the final image size.
Specific judgment and steps
- Identify the delivery constraint. If indexed color is required, record the maximum number of colors the receiving workflow accepts. If there is no such requirement, retain a full-color version for the final delivery rather than treating indexed mode as a general quality improvement.
- Open
Image → Mode → Indexed. Begin withGenerate optimum paletteand the largest permitted value, up to GIMP's documented 256-color default. UseUse web-optimized palette,Use black and white (1-bit) palette, orUse custom paletteonly when that palette is part of the project requirement. These choices are palette strategies, not interchangeable quality presets. See the GIMP Indexed mode documentation. - Make comparison copies or record each trial. Reduce the maximum color count only as far as file or palette requirements demand. Inspect the sky, skin-like gradients, small colored details, and transparent edges. A lower count can make broad transitions visibly step through solid bands.
- Compare
Noneand every available dithering filter at the chosen color count. Dithering does not add palette entries; it approximates a missing color with clusters of colors that are present. Choose the result with the least distracting pattern at delivery size, not the one that looks best only when enlarged. - If the image contains text layers that must remain editable, leave
Enable dithering of text layersoff. GIMP states that dithering text layers makes them uneditable. If the text is final artwork, record that editability has been intentionally relinquished. - For animation, make a separate comparison using
Positioned Color Dithering. The documentation identifies it as well adapted to animations, but it does not promise the best result for every animation.
This guide covers only the indexed-palette conversion and its dithering controls. It does not provide a numeric-precision conversion procedure; do not use this worksheet as instructions for a separate float-to-integer conversion.
Acceptance worksheet with a concrete hypothetical
Use one row per trial. The values below are hypothetical observations, not GIMP guarantees or a prediction of a particular filter's output.
| Trial | Palette and limit | Dithering | Hypothetical observation at target size | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Optimum, 256 | None | Sky shows three broad bands; lettering remains editable | Reject for the sky |
| B | Optimum, 256 | Floyd-Steinberg normal | Bands are less obvious, but fine grain appears near dark text | Compare against C |
| C | Optimum, 128 | Floyd-Steinberg reduced color bleeding | Sky has a repeating texture and distant cloud detail is less convincing | Reject despite lower palette |
| D | Custom, 64 | None | Flat illustration colors match the approved swatches; no editable text is required | Accept if the delivery requires this palette |
| E | Optimum, 256 | Positioned Color Dithering | Hypothetical animation review shows a more stable-looking pattern between frames | Consider for animation only after frame review |
Record the actual palette type, color limit, filter, visible sky artifacts, and text-layer state. The acceptance decision belongs to the project's target dimensions and content. A visually acceptable still image is not automatically an acceptable animated result.
Limits and the next step after failure
Dithering cannot restore colors that the selected palette does not contain; it only creates an approximation from available colors. Converting the result back to RGB also does not recreate discarded colors. If every indexed trial produces objectionable sky texture or banding, return to the full-color master and confirm whether indexed delivery is genuinely required. If it is required, ask the receiving party whether a larger palette, a different permitted palette, or a different delivery format is acceptable. For text that must still be edited, redo the conversion from a version where text dithering was not enabled. GIMP also notes that GIF transparency is one bit; apparent partial transparency may require a separate treatment, so do not assume indexed color preserves soft alpha edges.
Three short questions
Should I always choose 256 colors?
No. Use the largest limit allowed by the delivery requirement as the starting comparison. A smaller palette can be appropriate for a deliberately restricted illustration, but inspect the gradient rather than selecting it only to reduce colors.
Is dithering a repair for missing colors?
It is an approximation, not a restoration. Compare the pattern at the intended display size and with nearby text or edges.
Which filter is best?
GIMP's documentation says the result cannot be predicted in advance. Compare all available filters on the current image; use Positioned Color Dithering as a separate animation candidate, not as a universal default.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.