GIMP rounds the corners when you use Select → Grow on a rectangular selection. This is a documented peculiarity of the Grow command, not evidence that the rectangle tool was drawn incorrectly. If the required result must retain square corners, construct the target with the Rounded Rectangle command set to a 0% radius instead.
Diagnosis and Steps
The relevant trigger is specific: start with a rectangular selection, then increase it through Select → Grow. GIMP’s documentation says that this operation produces rounded corners. The dialog lets you enter the growth amount and choose a unit, but the documented issue here is the shape of the resulting corners, not a mistaken layer boundary or hidden selection.
Use this sequence on a duplicate or a deliberately disposable image:
- Create or identify the original rectangular selection and record its intended position, width, and height.
- Choose Select → Grow, enter the required expansion amount, and apply it.
- Zoom in on all four corners. Treat visible curvature as the expected Grow result when the starting selection was rectangular.
- Undo or otherwise return to the same original rectangle, then use the Rounded Rectangle command to construct the intended target selection.
- Set that command’s radius to 0%, using the same target boundary you intended to obtain after growth.
- Compare the two selections at the corners and along the outer edges before applying a fill, stroke, mask, or deletion.
The alternative is documented as a way to avoid rounded corners; it is not a claim that Grow has an option to preserve square corners. See the official GIMP Grow documentation.
Acceptance Worksheet
The following is an author-proposed comparison, not a software test or a guarantee about pixel counts. The numbers are hypothetical so that the acceptance decision is explicit.
| Check | Hypothetical observation | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Same target rectangle | Both candidates are intended to cover x=120–319 and y=80–229 | Continue only if the comparison uses the same boundary |
| Grow candidate | The four corners visibly curve after a 20 px growth | Classify as the documented Grow behavior |
| 0% alternative | The candidate is constructed with Rounded Rectangle at 0% radius | Use this candidate when square corners are required |
| Corner inspection | At 800% zoom, no curved transition is visible at any corner | Accept the corner shape; do not infer an unrecorded pixel count |
| Edge inspection | The top, bottom, left, and right limits align with the planned target | Accept the boundary only if both shape and extent meet the brief |
Record the command used, the radius setting, and the intended boundary. This prevents a later comparison from mixing a rounded Grow result with a differently sized replacement.
Limits and Next Steps
A 0% radius alternative addresses the documented corner-shape requirement. It does not establish that every selection operation, tool, unit, antialiasing setting, or version will produce identical pixel-level edges. The supplied documentation also does not provide a general formula for corner dimensions or a pixel-count acceptance threshold.
If the alternative still appears rounded, first confirm that the active construction command was actually Rounded Rectangle and that its radius field reads 0%. Then inspect the selection boundary at a higher zoom and compare the intended outer limits. Do not conclude from a faint display line alone that the stored selection has a different geometry. If the task requires exact pixel accounting beyond the documented behavior, define that requirement separately and verify it with a method appropriate to the project.
Three Short Questions
Does Grow always round every selection?
The cited documentation specifically describes the peculiarity for rectangular selections. Do not extend that statement to other selection shapes without separate evidence.
Can I keep using Grow and turn rounding off?
The supplied documentation gives the 0% Rounded Rectangle construction as the alternative. It does not document a Grow switch that preserves square corners.
Is this a layer or canvas problem?
For this symptom, begin with the selection command and its starting shape. The documented mechanism concerns Grow changing a rectangular selection’s corners, not the size of a layer or canvas.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.