
Use an Add mask for the object's outer region and a Subtract mask for its interior opening, both attached to the same effect. Final Cut Pro combines effect masks within a single effect. Masks attached to different effect instances do not form one shared subtraction operation.
Key Takeaways
- Put the outer and inner masks under the same intended effect.
- Subtract excludes an area; a second Add mask expands the affected area.
- Inspect mask order when several Add, Subtract or Intersect operations interact.
Define the region you want to change
For a photo-film detail shot, imagine a decorative ring whose surface needs a subtle color treatment while the scene visible through its center should remain unchanged. An outer shape alone includes both the ring and its opening.
The task is to describe the affected region accurately, not simply to make the effect less intense. Reducing the overall adjustment can conceal the mistake while weakening the intended correction.
Combine the masks on one effect
Select the clip and locate the intended effect in the Video inspector. In the Effects section, use Add Shape Mask beside the effect name to create the outer mask, then click it again for the opening. Beside each mask name, open the blend-mode pop-up menu: choose Add for the outer region and Subtract for the opening. Add Color Mask is the corresponding button when the mask should be based on color instead of a shape.
Apple documents Add, Subtract and Intersect blend modes for effect masks. It also states that these modes interact within one effect, rather than across separate effects. If the inner mask is attached to another copy of the correction, move back to the actual effect structure and diagnose that scope first.
Confirm that the effect supports the built-in masking controls described by Apple. The guide excludes effects in the Keying and Masks categories from this particular workflow.
Inspect order and movement
Apple says mask operations run sequentially from the top of their list. With several masks, the same shapes can produce a different result when ordered differently. Drag mask entries up or down in the Video inspector list to change that order. For the ring example, retain the outer Add before the hole Subtract, then compare the ring surface and the scene seen through its center.
Check the hole, the object edge and the area outside the object. In the illustrative ring shot, the ring should receive the treatment, while the center and surrounding scene retain their intended appearance.
If the object moves, review the entire shot. A correct region on one frame does not prove that the mask follows changing perspective or an obstructing hand.
Accept the effect in context
Compare the corrected shot with its neighboring shots. The viewer should see the intended detail rather than a conspicuous hole-shaped error. Export a short segment and inspect it at the final delivery size.
For moving shapes, use the separate rigid-mask versus changing-silhouette check. When changing a tracked frame, also distinguish a single-frame correction from a whole-clip adjustment.
Source: Apple's guide to combining effect masks.
Related tasks
- Why Does a Tracked Mask Follow a Dancer but Miss the Arms and Clothing?
- Why Did Fixing One Tracked Mask Frame Move the Mask Throughout the Whole Clip?
Sources and scope
- Apple: Combine multiple effect masks: Add/Subtract/Intersect operations, same-effect scope, sequential mask order, and excluded Keying/Masks effect categories.
Prepared by Imagild Editorial, the company editorial team responsible for these guides. AI assisted research and drafting. This is documentation-based guidance, not a claim of hands-on testing or independent review. Report a correction.
Cover: Pignatta / Pixabay, Content License. The city photograph is an illustrative source asset; it does not show this application or a test result.