Do not use one region of a color negative to set every part of its conversion. In darktable 5.6, choose the film type first, use unexposed film base for D min, exposed image content for D max, and dark lowlights for scan exposure bias. Then assess color casts and make the paper-style tone decisions. This keeps material, negative range, and print appearance as separate decisions.
Decide what each sample can tell you
Before opening Negadoctor, check how the negative was captured. For a camera photograph, the manual recommends using the sensor range without clipping, setting white balance for the illumination, applying the standard or enhanced camera matrix in Input Color Profile, and avoiding tone-mapping modules such as Filmic RGB or Base Curve during negative development. It recommends a linear Rec. 2020 working profile or an ICC profile for the film emulsion. These are input conditions, not Negadoctor sliders. See the darktable 5.6 Negadoctor preparation guidance.
Work through the controls in their displayed order:
- Set Film Stock to color or black and white. Follow the text label; a control's color is not a reliable way to identify its type.
- In Film Properties, sample only unexposed film base for color-base D min. For black-and-white film, the manual says the base-color control can remain at white. Do not use photographed scene content as a substitute for missing base data.
- Set D max from exposed image areas only. Exclude the unexposed border. The picker estimates a value intended to use the histogram without clipping; if adjusting manually, watch the right edge for clipped highlights.
- Set Scan Exposure Bias from the darkest lowlights, or from the whole image with unexposed base excluded. Check the histogram's left edge for clipped shadows.
- In Corrections, use the picker to set shadow color-cast sliders by selecting a trustworthy neutral gray shadow region. If needed, then use a trustworthy neutral gray highlight region that is not properly balanced to set highlight white balance. The shadow adjustment can also affect highlights, so do not reverse that order.
- In Print Properties, decide paper black, paper grade, paper gloss, and print exposure. These are creative tone choices after inversion, not measurements of the film base or negative range. Check the histogram at both ends as you refine them.
If the scan contains no unexposed border, the documented alternative is a separate image of an unexposed area from the same film. Measure D min from that image and paste the setting to other images from that film. Record that the value came from a separate base image; do not claim the scene itself supplied it.
Use a sample-and-review worksheet
The following is a hypothetical review record, not a darktable test or a prescribed numerical result. Its observations are invented to demonstrate decisions. Record which region supplied each value and exclude visible dust and scratches from picker selections: the manual warns these can skew sample data.
| Sample or check | Hypothetical observation | Decision to record |
|---|---|---|
| Unexposed base | A clear border exists; a scratch crosses one corner | Select clean base only; note the scratch was excluded; use this area for D min |
| Exposed image | The chosen rectangle contains a bright sky and no border | Use as the D max sample; inspect the histogram's right edge for clipping |
| Dark lowlights | A shadow area contains a dust spot | Exclude the spot; use a clean dark region for exposure bias, then check the left edge |
| Neutral candidates | A shadow is plausibly neutral; no reliable neutral highlight is identified | Correct shadow cast first; leave highlight correction undecided rather than guessing |
| Paper appearance | After technical settings, the histogram still approaches an edge | Reassess paper controls and print exposure; do not compensate by changing D min from scene content |
As an author-recommended comparison method, keep the region choices and observations in this table beside the image while adjusting one stage at a time. The table is an audit aid, not an official picker algorithm or a guarantee that any sample will produce a particular appearance.
Limits and what to do next
A sample can only represent the region actually selected. If the holder hides the unexposed film, do not substitute a bright scene area: obtain a separate image of unexposed base from the same film, measure D min there, and document the source. If no matching base image is available, the manual does not specify an equivalent substitute; do not present a guessed D min as a measurement.
If camera capture clipped the negative or its illumination white balance is uncertain, revisit the capture input before relying on later color adjustments. If no trustworthy neutral shadow or highlight exists, the correction pickers lack the reference described by the manual; leave that correction unresolved rather than treating a colored object as neutral. If D max or exposure bias pushes the histogram beyond an edge, revise that technical setting before trying to repair the clipping with paper controls. These controls have different roles, and paper gloss or grade cannot recover detail absent from clipped input.
Common questions
Can I use the whole image for D max?
The documented picker requires exposed negative only. Exclude unexposed base; the manual allows the whole image for exposure bias only when that base is excluded.
Should I change color corrections on every negative?
No. The manual says they are mainly for deteriorated base or a substantial difference between scanning illumination and the original scene lighting. Apply them only when the cast and a suitable neutral candidate justify it.
Does paper grade have to be 4?
The documented default is 4. The manual says that, if earlier settings went well, default minus D max would normally leave a value between 2 and 3. Treat that as a check described by the manual, not a universal target or substitute for evaluating the image.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.