If you want to intensify color without pushing already vivid areas as hard, compare global vibrance first. Choose global chroma when you want a proportional chroma change while keeping hue and luminance constant. Choose global saturation when you want a perceptual adjustment that changes both chroma and luminance. These controls are not interchangeable, and the best choice depends on which dimensions of color you want to move.
Decide what should change
Use this order to make the choice in darktable’s Color Balance RGB module:
- Identify the actual goal. If the image should stay at the same luminance, start with global chroma. If low-chroma areas need more attention than vivid ones, compare global vibrance. If you want color and perceived brightness to change together, compare global saturation.
- In the Master tab, change only one control at a time. Make a modest adjustment and inspect the same areas before and after; do not infer the result from the control name alone.
- Check both neutral or subdued colors and already vivid colors. If the vivid area is the first to become distracting, undo that change and compare vibrance rather than stacking another global increase.
- Look for changes in luminance as well as color strength. If luminance must remain stable, favor chroma; if the image needs a perceptual lightness shift along with chroma, saturation may suit the goal better.
- Keep the version that meets the visual target across the image, not merely the one that makes a selected patch strongest.
The manual describes global chroma as a proportional adjustment to chroma at constant hue and luminance. In Color Balance RGB’s scene-referred workflow, linear chroma grading applies that proportional operation in the module’s dedicated linear RGB grading space; this does not mean that the whole module processes in one linear space, since its technical information distinguishes linear RGB input from non-linear RGB processing and output. Perceptual saturation changes both luminance and chroma in the selected perceptual color space; the 5.6 manual provides JzAzBz (2021) and darktable UCS (2022) saturation formulas. Global vibrance affects chroma across the image while prioritizing low-chroma colors. See the Color Balance RGB manual for the control behavior and the saturation-or-chroma FAQ for how the manual frames the choice.
Use a comparison worksheet
The following is a hypothetical acceptance comparison, not a report from running darktable. Imagine a street scene with a neutral wall, a vivid red sign, and a person’s skin. Compare each control separately at a small, visually useful adjustment. Record observations rather than assuming a fixed numerical response.
| Control compared | Hypothetical observation to record | Decision cue |
|---|---|---|
| Global chroma | An ideally neutral wall should remain essentially unchanged because zero chroma is not increased by a proportional chroma operation; if a visible cast appears, check whether the wall already has a low-chroma cast, gamut mapping, or another module is involved. The sign becomes more intense, while skin luminance should remain unchanged | Keep it if stable luminance matters and the sign remains acceptable; do not treat this control as a way to add a hue to neutral pixels |
| Global saturation | Wall, sign, or skin may change in both color strength and apparent brightness | Prefer it if the combined perceptual change fits the intended look |
| Global vibrance | Wall or subdued skin appears to gain more color than the already vivid sign | Prefer it if low-chroma regions need emphasis without overdriving the sign |
For each pass, note three things: perceived color strength, apparent brightness, and whether the hue seems to shift. These are visual checks, not guarantees about individual pixels. The manual states that the relevant chroma and saturation operations maintain hue; a perceived shift or an out-of-gamut source color warrants closer inspection rather than assuming the control is a hue-shift tool.
Limits and next steps
Global vibrance prioritizes low-chroma colors, but it is still an image-wide control; it does not select a particular object. If only the sign or only the skin needs adjustment, do not keep increasing a global control to solve a localized problem. Use an appropriate masked or local workflow in darktable if you can define the target reliably, then inspect the boundary and other affected regions.
Color Balance RGB also applies soft gamut clipping at its output. The manual notes that this can affect colors that were already outside the pipeline RGB gamut, even when the module is enabled without a deliberate adjustment. If the comparison looks unexpected, inspect the working color space and the image’s starting colors, then test one control at a time. For a real monochrome result, the manual recommends the luminance-based black-and-white preset in Color Calibration rather than relying on a -100% global chroma setting.
Common questions
Does chroma preserve hue and brightness? The documented global chroma operation is at constant hue and luminance. That does not guarantee every input color will look equally perceptual: its working space is not fully perceptually scaled.
Is vibrance just saturation with another name? No. The manual describes global vibrance as prioritizing low-chroma colors. Saturation changes both luminance and chroma in a perceptual space.
Which control makes a pastel look? The manual identifies saturation as the more suitable direction for reaching pastel colors. Judge the result in the actual image, because the control also affects luminance.
Sources and next step
This guide interprets public documentation and uses explicitly hypothetical acceptance examples, not application tests. Controls and availability can change; verify the cited manual against your installed version.
For work created in Imagild, carry the input requirements and acceptance checklist into the photo editor. The external software controls discussed above belong to their respective products.