Two hand drawings can overlap because their controls independently show each one rather than replace one with the other. Adobe Character Animator distinguishes individual triggers from swap sets, which show one trigger at a time within the set. Inspect the trigger membership before painting out the old hand or changing the character's layer order.
Decide which drawings are alternatives
List the hand states that occupy the same role: relaxed hand, pointing hand and open palm, for example. Those may need mutual exclusion. A held prop or a separate sleeve is different; hiding it whenever the hand changes could break the illustration. Define the visual state model before grouping controls.
Keep the approved neutral pose and layer tree as a reference. If the hand designs also change forearm length or wrist placement, fix or approve that design issue separately. A swap set can manage visibility, but it does not reconcile incompatible artwork geometry or supply a missing wrist.
Audit the trigger-to-layer links
Select each trigger and inspect which layers it actually controls. A correctly named gesture can still point at an unrelated duplicate. Check that the alternatives belong to the intended swap set and that the desired default state is identified. Do not assume sibling layers automatically share the required trigger relationship.
Adobe also notes that other behaviors can control layer visibility separately from the Triggers behavior. If an old hand remains visible after the set appears correct, inspect whether another behavior, trigger or always-visible copy is showing it. Repeatedly rearranging the same layers without tracing ownership may only hide the overlap in one pose.
A proposed three-state hand test
For a fictional presenter, use relaxed, pointing and open-palm artwork. This is an original control-review exercise, not an executed puppet test. Keep the torso and sleeve visible throughout and test every change in both directions.
| Requested state | Must be visible | Must be absent |
|---|---|---|
| Relaxed | Approved resting hand | Pointing and open-palm alternatives |
| Pointing | Correct pointing hand | Old resting hand |
| Open palm | Correct open palm | Other competing hands |
Press and release the assigned controls according to the intended trigger behavior. Record the return state, not merely the moment while a key is held. If two controls are invoked together, inspect the set's supported priority rule rather than calling whichever one wins random.
Review the wrist through the transition
Watch the actual change at normal playback speed. The selected hand should meet the wrist without a sudden jump, duplicate fingers or a disappearing sleeve. A perfectly exclusive but geometrically misplaced hand still fails the performance. Record any designed discontinuity, such as an intentionally snappy illustrated gesture.
Save the set membership, default and accepted state examples with the external puppet. Imagild can contribute the visual character or pose references, but it does not create Adobe's trigger visibility logic. The handoff is complete when the animator can select each approved alternative, restore the intended rest and keep permanent artwork stable. It is not complete merely because the second hand can be made visible.